Dalton McGuinty resigns

This week, Dalton McGuinty called it quits after nine tired years as Premier of Ontario. The announcement came as a surprise to all as the details came in two announcements just hours apart on Monday.

Before he stepped down as Premier, McGuinty used his constitutional powers to prorogue the legislature dodging a motion of contempt leveled against his government’s energy minister Chris Bentley who only on Monday produced an additional 20,000 pages of documents regarding the building of two new gas-fired electricity plants in Ontario. The situation is familiar for Canadians as motions of contempt — one for the failure to produce documents — were brought before the federal House of Commons against the government of Stephen Harper prior to the election which granted him a majority in 2011.

The outcome here, however, is unfamiliar. Dalton McGuinty’s government was running out of fuel. Having previously won two majority governments, the last election resulted in a minority. The gas-plant imbroglio is rooted in that previous election; cynics and neutral observers noting alike that the construction of two such plants were politically motivated attempts to secure two seats in order to guarantee that third majority. The previous by-election was McGuinty’s last hope to achieve peace and place a cone of silence over the legislature with a majority. The result was not so fortunate for the Premier.

So, McGuinty prorogued.

Nothing constitutionally amiss with that, yet the reaction among Liberals, journalists, and the left has been quite muted about the issue. In 2010, we saw a Facebook group of 20,000 Canadians reach a level of national prominence after the Toronto Star decided to promote it on their front page. The Canadians Against the Prorogation of Parliament are notably silent today. In one month during that prorogation by Stephen Harper, I counted 1,561 articles written by Canada’s establishment press about this so-called affront to democracy. Perhaps predictably, and calculated by team McGuinty, the media could be distracted by something else.

Will Dalton McGuinty run for leader of the federal Liberal Party?

There was never a greater attempted ruse in Canadian politics this year than Dalton McGuinty’s attempt to deflect from the mounting corruption of his government at Queen’s Park — eHealth, ORNGE, secret deals with private energy firms, misadventures in wind and solar doubling the provincial debt and taking the province to “have-not” status in Confederation — than to leak an exclusive to the Canadian Press about the leadership team forming around Dalton McGuinty as he refused to rule out a bid for federal leadership.

The Canadian consensus media raised a five-alarm fire alarm on Stephen Harper’s constitutionally politically-motivated prorogation in 2010, while mentioning McGuinty’s as an aside in 2012. Bigger issues on the national agenda than the “fate of democracy” to be sure: the issue-challenged glam son of Pierre Trudeau was potentially being challenged by the last successful politician of the Laurentian Consensus media elite. (Gossip-hungry, issue-abstaining members of the Ottawa chaterrati will be enticed by the news that young Justin was ushered out of the Nova Scotia Liberal leader’s dinner fundraiser to be briefed on McGuinty’s retirement and possible challenge. It is reported that the young Trudeau returned to his seat looking ashen and deeply concerned. Good golly!)

There are serious issues to discuss. While Ontario has faltered on its fiscal footing, betting poorly on the dominating energy infrastructure of the first half of the 21st century and while the Canadian west is booming and preparing, building pipelines west (and eventually south) to emerging energy markets globally, the central Canadian media pines for the old times. It’s no coincidence that Liberal parties federally and in six provinces provincially are looking to elect new leadership (seven soon with Clark losing in BC). Canada is changing and looking to address new challenges and and energy- and resource-hungry world with action instead of cynical immovable inertia. Our old Liberal kings and their palace guards in the mainstream media are looking more and more like relics of another age.



  • carolyn

    What, he didn’t do enough damage to us here in Ontario, now he thinks he is going to move on to the Federal level?? Heaven help us all if the Liberals get back in power in Ottawa!!

  • liz J

    Great choice for the Federal Liberals if they want someone who makes a mess and then walks out leaving someone else to clean it up.

    It’s bordering on scandalous that he would resign and prorogue given the scandals and state of affairs of a province mired in debt with taxpayers struggling to pay high energy bills. Of course we all know proroguing is only a bad thing if Conservatives do it.

    The media will help him all the way should he decide to offer his services to the floundering LPC. As Bob Fife has said on national TV he had a few “minor scandals”. Those of us who watched this unfold don’t feel the scandals are too minor, we don’t know the half of it and that’s just the way McGuinty wants it, thus he scuttled out and closed the door.

  • kenn2

    While I’m no big fan of McGuinty’s prorogue, there’s a very big difference between this and Harper’s 2010 prorogue. I don’t recall Harper resigning, for starters.

    Canada is changing and looking to address new challenges and and energy-
    and resource-hungry world with action

    Yeah, it’s the 1950s again, but with OIL!! Cool.

  • harebell

    Absolutely, I’d have no regrets about Harper proroguing once more if the liar actually resigned after doing it.

  • Brenda2600

    McGuinty DID NOT QUIT. He is in hiding and God help the Province of Ontario because only God know what he will be doing and SIGNING.

  • liz J

    So true Brenda. He didn’t get the majority he’s used to last election and was denied again in the By-elections in spite of his expensive gas plant maneuvers. He just couldn’t bear having his agenda interfered with by the opposition parties. He’s done the next best thing to continue his agenda and no one can interfere with him.

    We won’t be hearing any more about the scandals, the MSM will not be interested in doing any grunt work on those because they’re Liberal scandals, Bob Fife referred to them as “minor scandals”. Tell that to the people of Ontario paying high taxes, and over-the-top energy bills and the legacy of indebtedness we’ll be passing on to our grandchildren.

    After nine years no person with the a thought process beyond a turnip can blame this on Mike Harris.

  • kenn2

    Ontario electricity rates are roughly on par with Alberta’s, and within 10% of the rates in majority of other provinces. And less than in many major US cities.

    Natural gas is at historic lows (unless, like many Ontarians, you got suckered into a bad gas contract because of ‘deregulation’)

    So, I’m not seeing the struggling with ‘over the top’ energy costs. Just sayin’

  • kenn2

    B2600:only God know what he will be doing and SIGNING.

    Hey, leave Me out of this. Besides, what can he do/sign now that he couldn’t do before this week? Did he suddenly get a majority? You do know how bills get passed, right?

    lj:He didn’t get the majority he’s used to last election and was denied
    again in the By-elections ….
    He just couldn’t bear having his agenda interfered with by the
    opposition parties. He’s done the next best thing to continue his agenda
    and no one can interfere with him.

    So you already know that McGuinty was in a can’t-win situation with the minority, and uncooperative opposition… isn’t that when a prorogue is reasonable, or do you agree that Harper was actually wrong when he did it too?

    And same question to you – how does proroguing help the Liberal agenda and eliminate ‘interference’? (hint – it doesn’t)

  • caring 1

    Stand up in opposition of proroguing legislative assembly Rally at Queens Park join