Was Tyrone Benskin’s PMB about himself?

Today, the Huffington Post reports,

MONTREAL – The NDP has suspended a member from its shadow cabinet because of his chronic, long-term failure to pay taxes.
Tyrone Benskin has been stripped of his role as official-languages critic until he pays the taxes he owes.
The announcement follows a report that Quebec’s revenue agency has contacted the House of Commons to seize part of his salary because of more than $58,000 he owes the province for unpaid taxes between 2007 and 2011.

Benskin authored a private member’s bill which was put to a vote in 2012. Here is a summary of the bill from Benskin’s website,

The culture industry is one of the biggest sectors of the Canadian economy. But due to their often irregular hours and inconsistent incomes, artists are nearly always disadvantaged both by punitively high taxation during years of high earning and by being ineligible for a number of federal programs such as Employment Insurance (EI), the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and others.
Tyrone Benskin’s Bill C-427 will begin to level the playing field by allowing Canadian artists to average their income over a period, achieving considerable tax savings over two to five years. This would follow the example of Quebec and of a number of foreign countries.
This is a deeply personal project for Mr. Benskin, who has been an artist for over 30 years. C-427 is born of an intimate understanding of the numerous and pressing challenges faced by contemporary Canadian artists.

Is it not a conflict of interest for a Member of Parliament to be legislating on an issue that affects him directly? We’re all taxpayers of course, but doesn’t this legislation affect his particular case directly?

Mr. Benskin lost his shadow cabinet position today in the NDP caucus. Should we have sitting MPs that legislate specifically to their own interest? Should Benskin be facing the Ethics Commissioner instead? This appears to be a grossly unethical conflict of interest.

UPDATE: Benskin is ‘truly sorry’ and promises to pay his taxes.



  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=650582510 Don Morris

    Maybe he should ask Nigel Wright if he has any spare change.

  • B Cummings

    Of course! The Tyrone Benskin scandal has been on everyone’s lips these days! Stephen Taylor: He has his ear to ground.

  • B Cummings

    You know the Conservative Party of Canada is hopelessly in deep shit when Stephen Taylor won’t even begin to try and spin their way out of this one…..just ignore and deflect. Good luck with that.