Elmwood—Transcona, MB 2011 Federal Election Results Map

Elmwood—Transcona — 2011 Election Results

📌 The Canadian federal electoral district of Elmwood—Transcona was contested in the 2011 election.

🏆 Lawrence Toet, the Conservative candidate, won the riding with 15,298 votes (46.4% of the vote).

🥈 The runner-up was Jim Maloway (NDP-New Democratic Party) with 14,998 votes (45.5%), defeated by a margin of 300 votes.

📊 Other notable candidates: Ilona Niemczyk (Liberal, 5%).

Riding information

Auto generated. Flag an issue.

Elmwood—Transcona

Elmwood—Transcona was a federal electoral district in the northeastern corner of Winnipeg, Manitoba, encompassing the historically working-class neighbourhoods of Elmwood, Transcona, and East Kildonan, as well as part of North Kildonan. The riding was defined by its railway heritage — Transcona was founded in 1912 as a hub for the Canadian National Railway's repair shops — and its mix of modest residential streets, industrial zones, and newer suburban developments. It was one of Winnipeg's most competitive federal ridings, with a long history of NDP representation.

Candidates

  • Lawrence Toet (Conservative) — Lawrence Toet was born on January 2, 1962, the son of Dutch immigrants who came to Canada in the early 1950s. From 1984 to 2009, he was a partner at Premier Printing, a family-owned printing business based in Transcona. Toet was active in his community and ran on a platform emphasizing economic management and local accountability. His 2011 victory was a significant upset, making him the first non-NDP member ever elected in the riding. He would serve one term before losing to NDP candidate Daniel Blaikie in 2015 by just 51 votes.

  • Jim Maloway (NDP)* — Jim Maloway was born on November 10, 1952, and earned a Bachelor of Arts in political science from the University of Manitoba in 1975. He served as a New Democratic Party member of the Manitoba legislature from 1986 to 2008, representing the provincial riding of Elmwood for over two decades as a backbencher under the Howard Pawley and Gary Doer governments. In 2008, he made the jump to federal politics and won the Elmwood—Transcona seat. As an MP, Maloway introduced Canada's first air passenger bill of rights, which influenced the airline industry to adopt several of its provisions. After his narrow 2011 defeat, he returned to provincial politics and won back the provincial Elmwood seat later that year.

  • Ilona Niemczyk (Liberal) — Ilona Niemczyk ran as the Liberal candidate in Elmwood—Transcona, a riding where the party had historically struggled to gain traction against the dominant NDP and rising Conservative vote.

  • Ellen Young (Green Party) — Ellen Young ran as the Green Party candidate, finishing fourth with just over 1,000 votes in a race dominated by the tight Conservative-NDP contest.

About the Riding

Elmwood—Transcona was a predominantly working-class riding with deep roots in Winnipeg's railway and manufacturing history. The Transcona neighbourhood grew up around the Canadian National Railway shops, which opened in 1912 and for decades employed thousands of workers in locomotive repair and maintenance. While the railway's direct employment had diminished by 2011, the area retained its blue-collar character, with nearly a quarter of the labour force working in trades, equipment operation, manufacturing, or utilities. Industrial zones and rail yards remained prominent features of the local landscape.

The riding's population was diverse but predominantly English-speaking, with significant Ukrainian, German, and Polish heritage communities that reflected early twentieth-century immigration patterns. By 2011, newer waves of immigration had brought growing Filipino, South Asian, and other communities to the area. Household incomes were generally modest, below the Winnipeg average, and the riding's politics often centred on bread-and-butter issues like jobs, healthcare, and affordable housing.

Elmwood—Transcona had been NDP territory for virtually its entire existence, reflecting the labour-oriented politics of its railway and manufacturing workforce. Jim Maloway's defeat in 2011 was therefore a genuine shock — the first and, as it turned out, only time a Conservative candidate won the riding. The result was extraordinarily close, with Lawrence Toet winning by approximately 300 votes out of more than 32,000 cast, and Maloway subsequently launched a legal challenge of the results.

The 2011 outcome reflected broader trends in Winnipeg, where the Harper Conservatives made inroads in several traditionally NDP-leaning ridings by appealing to suburban homeowners and small-business operators on issues of economic management and tax policy. Ironically, the national NDP Orange Wave that swept Quebec barely helped the party in this Winnipeg stronghold, where the local contest turned on hyper-local campaigning and the Conservative ground game in the riding's newer suburban subdivisions.

Nearby Ridings